I do the same thing. Oh I only really watch MHA, Megalo, SAO, and Attack on Titan atm. Everything else is swiftly ignored. But this isn't posting with a condescending tone, it's just stating factual information, and the truth does hurt people. If Toonami were to get canceled, people would make up excuses instead of pointing to an obvious lack of variety or ingenuity in the programming. And how long has this been going on?
No, you aren't stating factual information. Your tone still comes off as rather condescending and your argument is basically complaining about the amount of shonen series and/or how the shows Toonami picks don't appeal to your tastes. The only point your making that I can kind of agree with is the lack of variety, but I'm not sure if that is as huge of a problem as you're making it out to be. Yes, there are a lot of shonen series on the block, but would people in the general audience be that familiar with those kind of series to be an issue? Dragon Ball Super, Hunter x Hunter and Black Clover are all shonen series, but I'm not going to mix up the characters or storylines from those series. I doubt that anyone would. I assume that the general audience involves more people who are just casual anime fans, so having a lot of shonen series might not be really any different for them if that is the case.
Honestly, my main concern with the amount of shonen series has more to do with how they lock up a slot for years on end more than anything else. That just limits what shows Toonami can pick up and risk making the lineup more stale
ZZenigundam said:
I thought Toonami would have been progressive and taken the reigns from Adult Swim Action, which, in its 10 year existence, was never once overloaded with shonen, at most half of the block was ever shonen, but Toonami is being programmed by the same people who ran the Cartoon Network Toonami in its final 3-4 years apparently, because you'll find nothing but shonen these days. I'm not gonna pretend that they haven't thrown everybody a bone or two with Hellsing Ultimate, Gundam Unicorn, or Parasyte, but those acquisitions are few and far between. And then they give in easily to popular demand, first they say on Pre-Flight "Oh we would never air a series from earlier than 2010" and then a few months later they air Outlaw Star HD, a very good show, but they really lost a lot of credibility with me.
Regardless of how you feel about the schedule, the Toonami crew have way more freedom and control over the block than they did when it was on Cartoon Network. I don't recall hearing them say on Pre-Flight that they wouldn't air a series earlier than 2010. They originally said that they wouldn't air anything older than Cowboy Bebop, so I'm not sure if they had changed their minds or if there was more to the conversation than just what you're saying here. I also still have no idea who Gundam Unicorn could be considered mature in any sense. I thought that it was boring as dirt and I doubt being familiar with Gundam lore would have made it any better for me.
ZZenigundam said:
The issue isn't my divergent taste, it's that these guys along with the internet have thrown impressionable anime fans into a whirlpool and now the end result is a block full of shonen that doesn't reach with more mature audiences. Even as a kid, I'm confident I wouldn't have felt these shows. Sword Art Online, I probably would have been into it, but the other shonen heck no. So.... Where was I going with all this? Adult Swim desperately needs a competitor to either take out of the game or change their ways, and I'm not talking Netflix or Crunchyroll, I mean they really need somebody to show them how this is really done. No good TV network programs the same things for years on end. Variety is a simple recipe for prolonged enjoyment.
I really don't understand why exposing "impressionable" anime fans to shonen series is such a bad thing in the first place. Those tend to be pretty popular even on streaming sites like Hulu and Crunchyrol, so it's not like this is just something that Toonami is doing here. Not to mention being exposed to shonen series doesn't mean that they can't eventually find and like other kinds of anime series out there. I'm not sure if they wanted to appeal specifically to mature audiences. They can air anime mostly uncut on Adult Swim, but that doesn't necessarily mean that they'd only want to have more edgy and mature kinds of series on the block.
Besides all that, I really don't like the idea that a "mature" show is automatically better than any shonen series or that those kind of shows would be more appealing/successful on the lineup. I hated Black Lagoon, Tokyo Ghoul and Akame ga Kill. The only "mature" series that Toonami has aired that I've liked was Parayste. The so called "mature" series usually come off as too dark or trying too hard to be edgy. I'd rather watch My Hero Academia and Mob Psycho 100 over any of the mature series Toonami has aired. I don't recall how well those mature series did ratings wise, but I don't think that they attracted a lot of attention during their runs. Megalobox isn't exactly mature, at least in the sense that I think you're using the term here for, or a shonen series, but it isn't bringing in huge ratings despite being a different kind of series for the block.
The problem with that theory is that the Toonami crew acceded through Pre-Flight that they only watch a few episodes of most of the series they acquire. They were trying to get the Viz dub of Sailor Moon before they were outbidded for it, without ever having seen it! Oh and so much for "no pre-2010 shows" huh? I'm convinced that Toonami's revival was brought about by the fans of the early 2000s era Toonami, actually I have no doubt because I felt that way 7 years ago. They wanted Gundam Wing (I hate it), Tenchi (strong dislike), Sailor Moon R, Cell Saga DBZ, Outlaw Star, etc even though the Toonami that got canceled was airing Blue Dragon, Ben 10, and Naruto.
I'm aware that they only watch a few episodes. I'm pretty sure I mentioned that to you in one of the other times you've complained about the lineup too and that they have mentioned it multiple times before in the past when people ask them how they choose a show for Toonami. I imagine that at least some of them have seen Sailor Moon before the Viz redub, so it's doubtful that they hadn't seen anything of the series before. Although, I don't think the Sailor Moon redub would have been a good fit for Toonami anyway.
The shonen on the original Toonami wasn't the reason why it was canceled though. Cartoon Network was just less and less interested in the block over time, which resulted in them having less time slots and new shows. I'm pretty sure Toonami was half reruns by the time it finished its run on Cartoon Network. They were also more interested in focusing on their own properties instead of trying to find some success with a third party property like with anime.
ZZenigundam said:
I KNOW for sure that most of the Toonami crew hasn't watched the series they put on in their entirety. How would Dimension W ever get on the air if they did? I honestly think they watched a handful of episodes of the shonen they've acquired in the past 6 years and decided "This is a #1 show on Japan, let's let it ride". No... that's exactly what happened. And I'm not trolling or hating on them, I'm just saying that these are EXTREMELY lazy programming tactics.
I can't really blame them for not watching the series they put on in their entirety. While that would give them a better impression on a series than just the first few episodes, I'm sure that they don't have time to do that, especially when their staff is still pretty small and I don't think that they're paid for their work on the block either. Plus, expecting them to watch an entire series before putting it on their lineup just wouldn't be feasible in most cases. Dragon Ball Super was still airing new episodes in Japan when the dub started and I don't know how much of Hunter x Hunter was dubbed when they were given the chance to air it. There might also be a time pressure in making their decision before losing out on a series. I'm sure that was the case with Dragon Ball Super since a lot of channels would have wanted to air a new Dragon Ball series.
I'm sure that they do factor in the popularity of a series, but since they decide on what to air now without anyone else telling them what to air like they did when the block was on Cartoon Network, I'm also pretty sure that they still enjoy the shows that they put on the block for the most part. There are only a couple of series where I think that they regret picking them afterwards, such as GXP, but for the most part, they've expressed their enjoyment in other series that they've picked up. I remember a comment saying that they were hoping to get Part Three or Part Four of Jojo because they like the series.
Yeah and that kinda frustrates me too because the Toonami I was introduced to as a kid had American shows, and now it's moving toward pure anime, which is something that was Adult Swim Action's identity, but I know I'd rather watch something like Clone Wars or Beware the Batman over all the shonen I don't watch on there. I liked Samurai Jack season 5 more than anything on Toonami except for Unicorn when it was premiering and that's saying a lot because when the original Samurai Jack started on CN, there were so many better shows on that I couldn't even consider it in my top 10.
While I can understand that frustration to a degree, they also don't really have a lot of choices here when it comes to western animation. They had some choices with shows like Beware the Batman and Thundercats, but since Cartoon Network wrote them off, they legally can't air those shows. Same with Sym-Bionic Titan, despite how fans would love for a continuation to be made like with Samurai Jack. Western cartoons that appeal to adults that they can air on the block are pretty minimal at best, so their hands are tied in that regard.
Dude, if you're referring to me, just know I hate Casshern Sins. That and Deadman had to have been emergency acquisitions just to get Toonami back because I know they didn't have much money or support with the revival might as well have been a Kickstarter revival, and I don't even think they have money now, but they have contractual obligations to fill and that's why we're seeing what we're seeing. I refuse to believe that they consciously and willingly pumping out these shonen on the airwaves, some of which they won't even finish (why acquire something that you won't finish?). We're looking for mature TV-MA level anime because anime on Adult Swim was intended to be what couldn't air on regular Cartoon Network and Toonami on Adult Swim has only aired a handful of those types of series and has perverted the whole idea. The way CN is going, next thing you know they'll have Sesame Street on their airwaves and move Total Dramarama to Toonami.
This is one reason why I really have a hard time taking your claims against Toonami seriously. Because Toonami isn't full of TV-MA level anime, they might as well just air preschool shows or Total Dramarama on the block? That's a pretty ridiculous leap. Adult Swim has been full of TV-PG and TV-14 rated shows/episodes before. It's not like TV-MA was the only rating the block had before Toonami came around. TV-MA is also not a mark of guaranteed quality. I would still rather watch a good shonen series over a dark edgy "mature" series.
Plus, I can't really see a lot of the anime Toonami has picked up airing on Cartoon Network without some significant edits/changes. SAO, Jojo, Hunter x Hunter, Attack on Titan and Megalobox definitely couldn't work on Cartoon Network proper. The fights are too intense, blood is shown frequently and/or death actually happens, so there wouldn't be a good way for those to fit on the channel without being chopped up into pieces. Dragon Ball Super would probably work with minimal edits and maybe Boruto too, although I don't know how the fight scenes work in that series or they do deal with characters dying. My Hero Academia might have worked for the first season, but I think that the fights in season two, especially against Stain, would have made editing for the Cartoon Network audience pretty difficult, if not impossible. This is all rather moot considering that Cartoon Network doesn't have any interest in anime nowadays, not even with toyetic series, so if these shows wouldn't be on Toonami, they wouldn't be on Cartoon Network either.