Paramount Skydance Corp. management may not have the experience needed to manage the large amount of debt that will come from a merger with
Warner Bros. Discovery Inc., according to Arete Research.
The parent of CBS and other media businesses said it would buy Warner Bros. for $110 billion in late February, a deal that’s expected to close in September despite some regulatory hurdles. If the deal goes through it would create a media stock with $86 billion in gross debt, Arete’s Pierre-Marie d’Ornano said in a note to clients.
Arete downgraded Paramount to sell from neutral and cut the price target to $2 — the lowest among Wall Street analysts, according to data compiled by Bloomberg. The target implies a downside of about 80% from the stock’s closing price on Wednesday.
“Media mega-mergers are tough,” particularly from a historical standpoint, they wrote in a Thursday note. The tie-up between Paramount and Warner Bros. is the “most-levered media deal yet” and it’s “unclear that management has the experience to run a highly levered balance sheet.”
Arete’s target is 71% below the next lowest price target from Seaport Global Securities’ David Joyce which sits at $7. Meanwhile, Benchmark Co. and Morgan Stanley — the only two firm’s with buy-equivalent ratings on the stock — have price targets of $19 and $14, respectively. The average target of $11.40 across 15 analysts tracked by Bloomberg implies a 22% gain over the next 12 months.
“Paramount’s management team has a clear, disciplined plan to manage the balance sheet — and we’re already ahead of it,” a Paramount spokesperson said in an emailed statement to Bloomberg News. “Our capital allocation priorities have been consistent from day one: invest for long-term growth, restore investment-grade credit metrics, and return excess cash to shareholders once we get there.”
Shares in Paramount fell 3.9% to $9.37 at 2:36 p.m. in New York, extending declines for a fourth-straight session. The stock had fallen as much as 9.3% earlier in the session.
“The history of media mega-mergers is hardly inspiring, with frequently missed numbers due to ongoing linear declines, lofty streaming expectations and hard to manage capital structures,” d’Ornano wrote.
Arete sees the acquisition “facing similar challenges, but with more expensive debt and restrictive maintenance covenants.”
“Levered balance sheets require a particular approach and skillset, in our view, which is not obviously available in the Paramount Skydance team,” d’Ornano wrote, adding that mindset can be found at companies under cable-TV billionaire John Malone. Paramount is led by David Ellison.
While the US Justice Department
closed its probe into the Hollywood mega deal last month, it still faces some barriers. Top lawyers for several states have been
drafting a legal challenge that would open the door for an antitrust suit, with Oregon’s attorney general calling for a
60-day delay to closing the deal. Meanwhile, the UK government has
raised concernover the deal.