Speaking for myself, I would have personally given most, if not all the first season episodes favorable reviews than Stu (sorry buddy

). Compared to contemporary super-hero shows, they're certainly no better or worse and have some charm to them.
Certainly the animation in those early episodes, while primitive, does seem to be of a higher quality than Filmation's
Superman,
Aquaman and
Batman series. I guess Grantray-Lawrence's work on the 1966
Marvel Super Heroes cartoons wasn't a clear indication of their general level of quality! However, the nice animation of that first season clearly came at a price, since they went bust afterwards.
The Ralph Bakshi episodes that I mainly reviewed seem all the more disappointing to me considering that they came after that impressive first season. While I do appreciate some of the moody music and imagery, the animation quality is shockingly poor in those episodes, almost on a par with the
Marvel Super Heroes episodes (and they were done like that so they could crank lots of them out in a short space of time). Also, either Bakshi or the writers of the show clearly didn't care much for Spider-Man's rogues gallery, and so we instead end up with hoards of lesser, and often downright bizarre original adversaries. Stan Lee and John Romita clearly had some input in the first season, but ironically (since it was animated in New York) seem to have had very little to none input in the second season.
The last thing I'd like to do is to judge a show as old as this completely by modern eyes; I like to take stock of what the show was like in its original context. The DC super-hero shows (seemingly forgotten due to a lack of snazzy theme tunes) have one over on the
1967 Spider-Man's second and third seasons by virtue of them usually using characters and concepts from the comics. If Krantz Films' consistently didn't shun the same things for Spider-Man, since there was clearly nothing from stopping them, then poor animation or not, those later episodes would simply have been better in my opinion. For instance, those
Marvel Super Heroes cartoons are famed for having the most exceedingly primitive animation ever seen on TV, yet I find them very entertaining due to the quality of the stories (since they came almost word for word from the original high-quality comics of the time).
At the very least, I hope I have explained myself a little better; in any case, it's cool to see that the show has its defenders!